I Can Accomplish Anything if I Believe in Myself – Stephan James

The star of “Selma” and “If Beale Street Could Talk” chats to Ovations’ Samantha Ofole-Prince about stepping into Carl Weathers’ shoes, the power of the underdog, and building a legacy for artists of colour

When I spoke with Stephan James at the Beverly Hills, Bad Roman eatery on Sunday afternoon, one thing was clear within minutes: this is an artist who understands the weight of the stories he tells.

James belongs to a rare group of actors who go beyond popularity and come to embody a part of our shared history. He has played Congressman John Lewis in Ava DuVernay’s “Selma” and Olympic hero Jesse Owens in “Race,” and he starred in “Home Again,” a film about Caribbean deportees. Every one of those choices was deliberate.

His latest role puts him in the ring with a legend. In “I Play Rocky,” directed by Peter Farrelly, James plays the late Carl Weathers, the former Oakland Raiders linebacker who became Apollo Creed, Rocky Balboa’s unforgettable rival. The film tells the true story of how a struggling, unknown Sylvester Stallone, then working in a movie theatre and facing homelessness, wrote the screenplay for “Rocky” after watching a Muhammad Ali fight. He fought to star in it himself. The 1976 film was made on a shoestring budget and went on to win three Oscars. The cast includes Anthony Ippolito, AnnaSophia Robb, Toby Kebbell, P.J. Byrne, Jay Duplass and Matt Dillon.

James doesn’t appear until the film’s halfway point, but his arrival leaves a lasting impression.

Weathers passed away in 2024, which makes the responsibility of portraying him even heavier. James told me: “Every role presents a different challenge or a different way you want to go in and go about as you are filling their shoes to the best of your ability.”

What he wanted to capture was Weathers’ range. “The thing that made Carl so special was just the many qualities that he had. He is this larger than life figure and can be this charismatic, swaggerific guy, but he can also be intellectual and humorous and not take himself too seriously as well. It was really important for me to make sure that I was tapping into that essence of him.”

For James, the film’s themes hit close to home. “From an actor’s perspective, any artist can relate with being told no a hundred times and still chasing that yes, so I definitely related and resonated with it from that perspective. Rocky is one of the most important films in the history of films and is the underdog story. There hasn’t been a more profound underdog story in the history of cinema.”

He is amazed at how close the world came to never having “Rocky” at all. “If this didn’t happen this way or if this domino didn’t fall like this, we would never have had Rocky. I think it really makes the story all that much more unbelievable when you just realize what it took and how many things had to go right for Rocky to happen.”

The Emmy-nominated Canadian actor, whose parents hail from Jamaica, traces his path to his older brother, fellow actor Shamier Anderson. “I’ve always sort of recognized the artist in myself and how art spoke to me but I didn’t necessarily know how I was going to channel that myself. I remember going to theater performances my brother was in at theater school. The first seed was planted in my head that people from where I come from can do this and it can be rewarding and fulfilling and you know hopefully, maybe there’s a career I can build out of it. I was very lucky to be able to have done that.”

That seed has grown into a career that includes “The Piano Lesson,” “If Beale Street Could Talk,” “21 Bridges” and “Night Always Comes.” He was the first recipient of the Canadian Screen Awards’ Radius Award, and his performance in “I Play Rocky” has earned him a Critics Choice Supporting Actor Award. He is also a producer, with the space thriller “Beacon 23” and the upcoming film “The Journeyman” to his name.

James is just as committed to opening doors for others. With his brother, he launched the B.L.A.C.K. Academy (Building a Legacy in Acting, Cinema + Knowledge), a non-profit that creates opportunities for artists of colour in Canada. It hosts an annual award show, The Legacy Awards.

When I asked what he hopes audiences take away from the film, James returned to the story’s heart. “I can accomplish anything if I believe in myself and have perseverance, determination and a belief in the impossible,” he said. “I think this film presents those same qualities.”

Samantha Ofole-Prince is a U.S. based journalist and movie critic who covers industry-specific news that includes television, film and music.